Skip to main content

SCOTUS rules on Marriage Equality: the tl;dr version

By
The U.S. Supreme Court legalized same-sex marriage in all 50 states on Friday, June 26, 2015 in Obergefell v. Hodges, a 103 page decision which we read so you don't have to.  You should, but seriously, most of you probably won't.  Many people will just read that headline and know that there has been an important change in the status of legal relationships in the U.S.  Both the majority and dissents agree on one thing, this is a significant and far-reaching decision.

For full coverage of the decision itself and the legal impact, visit SCOTUS blog.

For now we're posting the tl;dr version of the majority and dissenting opinions:

Here is what each opinion seems to say about the author's view of marriage:

Robert's Dissent:    Marriage is an institution.
Scalia's Dissent:     Marriage limits your expression.
Thomas's Dissent:  Marriage has nothing to do with liberty.
Alito's Dissent:       Marriage is for procreation.

Kennedy's Majority Opinion:  All you need is love.

Below is a slightly more in depth analysis:

Majority Opinion written by Justice Kennedy and joined by Ginsburg, Breyer, Sotomayor and Kagan

tl;dr: Marriage is a fundamental right under 14th amendment due process and extends to same-sex couples because there is no rationale to deny benefits based on the societal reasons for promoting marriage.  This was not based on a typical equal protection analysis, but rather focused on the nature of marriage and why it's important in today's society and therefore represents an inalienable liberty.

Justice Roberts' dissent joined by Scalia and Thomas

tl;dr: Extending due process rights to marriage = judicial law-making because the history of marriage is clear and the legislative process was doing just fine.  Criticizes the majority for ignoring typical equal protection analysis.

Justice Scalia's dissent joined by Thomas

tl;dr: Scalia really wants you to know that he agrees with Roberts but wants to drop the pretense that he "respectfully dissents".  Also, Californians aren't real westerners and hippies have more fun (seriously, he said that).

Justice Thomas' dissent joined by Scalia

tl;dr: You think you know what "liberty" is? Well, do I have an irrelevant history lesson for you.  It basically involves proving that liberty and dignity can't be given to you by the government so people shouldn't care if the government endorses slavery or traditional marriage.  Change comes from within, man, so don't look to us for help. 

Justice Alito's dissent joined by Scalia and Thomas

tl;dr: Same sex marriage might have dire consequences... none of which he's willing to describe in detail other than to imply that religious freedom and democracy itself will be damaged by this decision.  


Labels:

Comments

  1. Doris TennantJuly 2, 2015 at 11:20 AM

    The best summary of the equal marriage decision I've seen--talk about the salient points--you got them down, including the dissents. Thanks so much!

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

2024 U.S. Presidential Party Platforms - What are the policy positions that could affect families?

By
While the laws that affect family formation, marriage and divorce are often made at the state level, there are also many policies and laws at the federal level that affect families and children.  Just some examples from recent years that have impacted families in my mediation practice include changes to the federal tax laws (such as  the elimination of the alimony tax deduction ) and U.S. Supreme Court rulings on same sex marriage and reproductive health rights.  In just over a month, the United States presidential election will have a significant impact on these federal policies going forward, and could choose the next appointments to the U.S. Supreme Court as well. In 2016 and 2020 we shared what each presidential platform said about families and policy regarding family formation and dissolution, and below we'll provide you an update on the 2024 presidential platforms.  As Maya Angelou said, "When someone shows you who they are, believe them the first time."...
1 comment
Read more

Updating your Divorce Agreement Template - More Lessons from Cavanagh v. Cavanagh

By
We recently posted a lengthy review of the the Massachusetts SJC decision in Cavanagh v. Cavanagh (2002)  which included some recommendations for drafting divorce agreements, also typically called Separation Agreements.  The Cavanagh case is best known for it's clarification of how the courts should evaluate support calculations when a case may have both alimony and child support.  However, the case also contained numerous rulings that should make practitioners review their Separation Agreement templates and change some of the ways in which they may have previously drafted certain sections. In this post we'll share actual language from the Gray Jay Endeavors, LLC form Separation Agreement template which addresses each of the issues raised by the Cavanagh decision.  If you are a professional interested in purchasing the full Separation Agreement template, check out Gray Jay's  forms subscription which includes editable Massachusetts court forms and financial st...
Post a Comment
Read more

Co-Parenting Coordinator Agreements - What They Can Do and How to Draft Them

By
Photo by Marcelo Silva on Unsplash Conflict between parents negatively affects children but for some parents it's hard to avoid conflict when separating or divorcing.  Loss, grief, and anger all make it difficult to co-parent and some parents need help overcoming those barriers. One of the professionals that can help parents reduce conflict by assisting them in making the necessary co-parenting decisions is a Co-Parenting Coordinator.  The duties of a Co-Parenting Coordinator can vary but often include assisting parents with decision making around: changes or clarifications of the existing parenting plan; exchanges of the child or children including date, time, place, means of and responsibilities for transportation; education or daycare including school choice, tutoring, summer school, before and after school care, participation in special education testing and programs, or other educational decisions; enrichment and extracurricular activities including camps and jobs; the c...
Post a Comment
Read more